Former Adelaide Crows captain Mark Bickley has dismissed calls for Port Adelaide’s head coach Ken Hinkley to resign, labelling such suggestions as “folly” and warning it would lead to complications. This discussion emerged following Port Adelaide’s substantial 91-point loss to Collingwood in their season opener, prompting North Melbourne great David King to question the wisdom of continuing with the current succession plan for Hinkley and assistant coach Josh Carr.
King argued that Hinkley’s departure is overdue, stating that the uncertainty surrounding his position creates ongoing tension within the team. He suggested that Hinkley should proactively step down to relieve the club of the pressure, which could otherwise become a recurring topic of discussion throughout the season.
In February, Port Adelaide announced that Hinkley would hand over the coaching duties to Carr after the 2025 season. While Hinkley has a commendable record, with seven finals appearances out of 12 seasons, his inability to secure a premiership has been a source of criticism.
Bickley, who led the Crows to premiership victories in 1997 and 1998, firmly disagreed with King’s perspective. He highlighted the potential ripple effects of an abrupt coaching change, questioning the logic behind simply terminating Hinkley’s contract. Bickley pointed out that such a move could leave the club without a crucial midfield coach, as Carr would need to step up to a head coaching role without a seasoned assistant in that pivotal position.
He elaborated that appointing interim coaches from the existing staff could lead to further disarray, compromising the development of younger players and overall team performance. Bickley advocated for a more measured approach, suggesting that Hinkley’s established experience should continue to benefit the club during this transition period while Carr gradually prepares for his future role.
While there is significant pressure on the Port Adelaide coaching staff, Bickley advised against hasty changes, asserting that maintaining stability within the coaching structure is vital for the success of the team moving forward.
As Port Adelaide prepares to face Richmond this Saturday, Bickley’s insights emphasise the importance of considering the broader implications of coaching decisions, rather than succumbing to immediate pressures for change.