Matthew Lloyd has identified three significant deficiencies in Carlton’s roster, which he believes contribute to their lack of premiership potential in 2025. Currently sitting outside the top eight, the Blues have suffered losses to both GWS and Sydney, raising concerns about their overall performance as they approach their bye week.
One of the main criticisms has been their disposal efficiency, but Lloyd emphasises that personnel issues are also a critical factor. He questions the strength of their running backs, suggesting that if Adam Saad is considered their best player in that position, he likely doesn’t rank among the top 15 in the league. Lloyd remarked on Nine’s Footy Classified that there is a clear need for improvement.
Lloyd further highlighted the deficiency in running midfielders, stating that while Sam Walsh may be their standout, he does not warrant a place among the best 25 to 30 players currently active. Additionally, he pointed out that Carlton lacks competent small forwards, contrasting them with other teams that possess multiple exceptional players in that role.
In discussing individual performances, Lloyd expressed disappointment in two-time Coleman Medallist Charlie Curnow, suggesting that he could show more determination on the field. Lloyd noted the alarming statistic that eight Blues players rank among the worst for inside-50 kicks, and he feels Curnow tends to give up too easily during challenges, especially when compared to other star forwards like Jeremy Cameron and Jesse Hogan.
Furthermore, there has been a shake-up in club management, as Damian Barrett reported that Graham Wright’s transition to CEO has been moved forward to July instead of the previously planned October. All these elements point to a challenging road ahead for Carlton as they attempt to regroup and improve after the bye, with hopes of mirroring the successful turnaround they achieved in the latter half of the 2023 season.