Andrew Johns, a legendary figure in rugby league, has raised concerns about Isaiya Katoa stepping in for Nathan Cleary in the upcoming Origin III. Drawing parallels with Jarrod Mullen’s early Origin experience, Johns reflects on the pressures that Katoa could face if selected. Mullen, who debuted in 2007 with only 31 NRL games under his belt, saw his confidence shaken following a disappointing loss in his first Origin match, which the Blues led at half-time but eventually lost 25-18.
As Cleary pushes to recover from injury in time for the match, discussions on Katoa’s potential replacement include names like Luke Metcalf, alongside the option of shifting Jarome Luai to halfback. While Johns acknowledges Katoa’s readiness, he fears the immense pressure of the Origin stage could hinder the young player, similar to Mullen’s experience, stating, “He’s ready to go, Isaiya Katoa, but you could burn him.”
Johns’s worries are compounded by tactical considerations, noting that both Katoa and Luai are primarily left-sided players, which could complicate their synergy in the game. He also highlighted Metcalf’s proficiency on the right side but admitted that Katoa possesses unique qualities that could make him a valuable asset.
Heading into Round 12, the competition for selection is fierce, with Metcalf leading the Dally M vote tally and Katoa close behind. Both players are showing promising form, but the Blues are eager for Cleary’s return. Despite resting for the upcoming match against the Warriors, Cleary’s father and coach, Ivan, conveyed optimism about his recovery from a minor groin concern.
The Blues are mindful of the looming series decider, scheduled for selection shortly after the upcoming matches, raising additional urgency for Cleary’s fitness. With a challenging schedule ahead, including a rapid turnaround to face the Bulldogs, the availability of their star halfback remains in question as the NSW squad braces for a critical match against Queensland.
In summary, Johns’s insights help shed light on the complexities and expectations surrounding the selection process as the Blues contemplate their strategies for the decisive game.