A court case spanning over four decades is currently in a state of limbo as Michael Martin, aged 70, disputes evidence against him regarding the alleged rape of Jessie Grace Lauder when she was in her 80s. Martin appeared at the Melbourne Magistrates Court recently, dressed casually after being granted bail earlier in the year.
Martin was arrested following DNA evidence that purportedly connects him to two assaults on Lauder at her home in Newport, one occurring in 1981 when Martin was 26 and another in 1983. Allegations state that Martin first attempted to rape Lauder while threatening her with a knife, before returning two years later and successfully raping her. Notably, he lived across the street from Lauder at the time.
Detective Richard Kelly provided details to the court, recounting how Lauder heard a loud noise before encountering a man she believed to be Martin at her door, who demanded money for sexual acts before attempting assault. During the later incident, Lauder reportedly heard glass breaking, and Martin allegedly threatened to kill her, urging her not to report the assault as she had done previously.
Lauder passed away in 1993, but her grandson, Malcolm Lauder, is actively pursuing the case in her memory. Although charges against Martin include attempted aggravated rape and aggravated burglary, he has yet to enter a plea.
Key DNA evidence, preserved until recent technological advances allowed for testing, was matched to Martin in 2022. Consequently, both the prosecution and defence have requested a delay in proceedings until October to accommodate the availability of a crucial DNA expert for the case. Martin’s lawyer intends to challenge the DNA evidence, highlighting its significance given that Lauder has passed away.
A committal hearing has been scheduled for October 17, allowing the defence to cross-examine witnesses involved in the matter. Meanwhile, Magistrate Leon Fluxman has extended Martin’s bail and instructed him to appear in person for his next court date, ensuring that he understands the proceedings ahead.
Martin’s bail was initially granted as a magistrate concluded that he posed no significant risk to the public, dismissing police concerns about his potential to influence witnesses, including Lauder’s grandson.
Support services are available for those affected by sexual assault, with the National Sexual Assault, Domestic and Family Violence Counselling Service accessible through 1800RESPECT (1800 737 732).