Phil Gould’s exasperation with the Bunker has reached new heights following a controversial game incident that saw Wayde Egan’s try disallowed while Dane Gagai’s goal was upheld, leading to widespread outrage. During the first half, Egan made a solo effort from dummy half and executed a strong hit-and-spin move against Gagai. Initially awarded a try, the decision was reversed upon review for a perceived double movement. Gould expressed disbelief over the situation, questioning why such a long-standing attempt was under scrutiny. He stated, “That’s been a try for 100 years, why is everyone second guessing this?” and remarked his frustration by suggesting he might leap from the commentary box if the try was overturned, which indeed happened.
In his dismay, Gould critiqued the Bunker for complicating the game, saying, “Rubbish, you’re making the game too hard.” Five minutes later, the incident escalated when Greg Marzhew’s off-the-ground pass to Gagai resulted in a try, further fuelling the controversy. Andrew Johns highlighted the questionable momentum of Marzhew’s play, adding, “That’s held… he stopped, there’s no momentum.” The fullback’s incredulous reaction captured the absurdity of the moment, leaving many spectators puzzled.
Earlier in the match, the Warriors had taken the lead through Adam Pompey before Fletcher Hunt brought Newcastle onto the scoreboard with a try in the 22nd minute. Gagai’s later effort put Newcastle ahead at 8-6, with Marzhew extending the score to 12-6 by halftime. Commenting on the extraordinary events of the first half, Darren Lockyer noted, “There’s been some odd moments in the first half and odd calls … Dane Gagai’s eyes said it all really,” reflecting the sentiment of players and fans alike regarding the perplexing officiating decisions.