Carlton’s aspirations for the finals took a significant hit with a disheartening 50-point defeat to Port Adelaide at Adelaide Oval on Thursday night, marking a serious blow to their chances of making the top eight. The final score read 16.14 (110) to 8.12 (60), leaving the Blues reeling after a recent loss to North Melbourne. With a 6-9 season record, their prospects for September now seem grim.
Following the loss to the Kangaroos, Carlton faced harsh criticism, particularly regarding their performance in this match. Notable figures such as David King condemned the team’s effort and execution. King remarked on his surprise at the poor display, citing their recent hard work despite inconsistent skills. Similarly, Adelaide great Mark Ricciuto expressed disappointment, stating the players’ effort simply wasn’t up to standard.
In a particularly dismal first half, Carlton scored only one goal, while Port’s Mitch Georgiades showcased his prowess by netting five goals—his second such feat in three weeks. Adding to Carlton’s woes, defender Adam Saad was substituted at halftime due to a concussion sustained from a collision with opposing ruckman Dante Visentini, raising concerns about player safety.
Despite this setback, pundits largely viewed the incident as accidental, suggesting that Visentini likely wouldn’t face punishment. Former player Jack Riewoldt commented on the nature of the bump, indicating that there was no malice involved, although caution should be exercised when attempting such moves.
Port Adelaide’s victory was vital as they climbed to 10th on the ladder, igniting their own finals hopes. Coach Ken Hinkley’s decision to make significant changes to his lineup before the match proved effective, contrasting sharply with the pressure mounting on Carlton’s coach Michael Voss. Although Voss is under contract for the upcoming season, criticism has intensified, even prompting AFL icon Buddy Franklin to call for his immediate resignation.
Despite some speculation on Voss’s future, former Essendon star Matthew Lloyd believes he will likely remain through the current season. As Carlton grapples with their disappointing performance and dwindling hopes for the finals, the question of their leadership and team direction looms larger than ever.