District Attorney Nathan Hochman has expressed his reasoning for supporting the continued incarceration of Erik and Lyle Menendez, who were convicted in 1996 for the murders of their parents. Hochman emphasised that the brothers must demonstrate “insight and complete responsibility” for their actions, noting their longstanding denial of the crimes and the inconsistent claims of self-defence against overwhelming evidence of premeditated murder.
Hochman stated that the brothers have deceived the public for over three decades, drawing parallels to the case of Sirhan Sirhan, who assassinated US Senator Robert F. Kennedy in 1968. Despite receiving substantial support as a low-risk prisoner, Sirhan was denied parole in 2022, with the governor citing a continuing threat to society—this, Hochman noted, was akin to the Menendez brothers’ failure to fully embrace accountability for their actions.
He indicated that fresh opportunities for resentencing may be considered if the brothers confess their past lies and acknowledge their crimes. While he acknowledged their positive changes, such as attaining degrees and favourable risk assessments, he firmly maintained that rehabilitation must come with genuine acceptance of their actions.
Currently, a resentencing hearing is scheduled for later in March, as the brothers seek release based on new allegations of abuse by their father, backed by the majority of their extended family. However, family members have rebuffed Hochman’s stance on their lack of eligibility for resentencing, arguing that Erik and Lyle have evolved significantly since their youth and have shown remorse for their deeds.
Hochman, who took office in December, is against a retrial for the Menendez brothers, contrasting sharply with his predecessor, George Gascón, who recommended a 50-to-life sentence, allowing potential parole eligibility. Hochman dismissed this suggestion as a political gesture.
In addition to pursuing resentencing, the Menendez brothers have also filed for clemency with Governor Gavin Newsom, who stated he would defer any decisions until receiving Hochman’s input. Newsom recently mandated a review by the state parole board to assess potential public risk should the brothers be released. Although Newsom did not comment specifically on Hochman’s remarks, he announced plans for a new parole process that could facilitate sentence reductions for more inmates.
Lastly, one relative has called for Hochman’s removal from the case, alleging bias, which the DA refuted, asserting his commitment to adhering to the facts and the law.