Paul Gallen has expressed strong disapproval of Newcastle’s recent decision to secure Eels playmaker Dylan Brown on a hefty 10-year deal reportedly worth $14 million, labelling the move as "irresponsible." Gallen voiced his concerns during an appearance on Nine’s 100% Footy, questioning the foresight of those responsible for the lengthy contract, given the physical nature of rugby and the potential for injuries that could affect Brown’s performance over time. He stated that if the deal doesn’t yield the intended results, the repercussions would fall on the decision-makers, not just the player.
In contrast, Phil Gould defended Newcastle’s bold choice, suggesting that the scarcity of top-quality playmakers has led to a sense of urgency in recruitment. The Sydney Morning Herald revealed that Brown, valued as a significant asset, confirmed his move to Newcastle after the 2025 NRL season via Instagram shortly after the report broke.
Gallen acknowledged the financial aspect of the deal, stating that he supports players receiving maximum compensation but remains sceptical about such long-term commitments, which could prove risky. He expressed hope that Brown would thrive in his new role and contribute to the team’s success.
Meanwhile, Parramatta’s management has recognised Brown’s exceptional skill set, stating they understand his decision to accept Newcastle’s offer, viewing it as a lucrative opportunity for him and his family. There is a possibility that the Eels might try to convince Brown to stay within the ten-day window allowed by NRL regulations, although they appear to be preparing for his exit.
Gould highlighted that Brown’s signing reflects the desperation clubs feel for quality playmakers, emphasising that success in the NRL often hinges on having elite talent in this position. He referred to Brown as a dynamic player, poised to make a significant impact alongside Knights fullback Kalyn Ponga, who is also well-compensated at $1.4 million annually on a deal set to run through 2027.
With Brown expected to be at the peak of his career, he will be 35 when his contract concludes in 2035, indicating both clubs view this acquisition as pivotal in their pursuit of premierships. Ultimately, while opinions differ on the viability of such a lengthy contract, it underscores the fierce competition and strategic decisions underpinning modern rugby league.