AFL icon Matthew Lloyd has expressed that the footy community would likely understand if Zach Merrett chose to leave Essendon in pursuit of premiership success elsewhere. The 29-year-old midfielder is poised to secure his sixth best and fairest award at the club, having taken on various roles amid an unfortunate string of injuries within the team. Despite Merrett’s personal achievements, the Bombers’ prospects of reaching the finals remain bleak, with more than 20 years since their last finals win.
In a recent discussion on Nine’s Footy Classified, journalist Sam McClure suggested that it may be time for both Merrett and Essendon to consider a trade, highlighting that many fans might struggle to accept such a move. Lloyd, however, pointed out that while it would be hard for club supporters, the broader audience might not fault Merrett if he sought greener pastures.
Merrett’s contract runs until the end of 2027, making it improbable for the club to entertain trade talks unless he expresses a desire to leave. Despite his loyalty to Essendon, Lloyd emphasised that without competing in finals, Merrett might miss out on significant moments that shape a player’s legacy. He reflected on the importance of finals appearances, comparing Merrett’s situation to that of Carlton’s Patrick Cripps, who recently had the opportunity to play in finals.
Lloyd acknowledged Merrett’s potential to leave for a team with a better chance of success, but noted that doing so might hinder his legacy as a one-club champion. He highlighted examples from football history, such as Matthew Richardson, who is celebrated as a Richmond legend even without a premiership title.
Merrett has previously turned down an offer from St Kilda that included a substantial pay rise, resulting in Essendon renegotiating his contract for a better salary, cementing his status at the club. Geelong great Jimmy Bartel remarked that it is now crucial for Essendon to present a compelling plan to keep Merrett engaged and motivated.
The conversation surrounding Zach Merrett continues as Essendon grapples with its long-standing struggles to return to finals contention, which last occurred in 2021. As the Bombers endure a challenging phase, the club must focus on strategies not only to retain their star midfielder but to revive their performance on the field.