Carlton Football Club is facing significant challenges, particularly highlighted by their failure to convert scoring opportunities inside 50, as noted by Geelong legend Jimmy Bartel. During their round 11 match against GWS, the Blues dominated contested possessions but still ended up losing by 28 points, conceding 110 points in the process. Bartel asserted that this ongoing issue has stemmed from a deficiency in the club’s development and coaching strategies, which he believes has persisted for over two years.
Despite their strong performance in contested possession, Carlton squandered numerous chances, especially in the first half. Bartel criticises the club’s approach, suggesting their focus on stoppage play hampers their effectiveness near goal. He pointed out that development should not be limited to younger players, citing his own experiences in player development even late in his career. Bartel emphasised the need for better kick-to-advantage strategies when entering the forward 50, stating that the poor statistics of key forwards and midfielders reflect inadequate skill training.
In agreement with Bartel, former Essendon coach James Hird called the situation an indictment on Carlton’s overall player development. Hird pointed out that all players, not just the younger ones, must continuously practice their skills, including kicking to specific targets. He shared insights from his conversation with Essendon captain Zach Merrett, highlighting the importance of varied kicking techniques, which appear lacking at Carlton.
Looking ahead, Hird believes Carlton has the potential to win their next three matches against Essendon, North Melbourne, and West Coast, but he remains sceptical about their genuine chances of making the finals. He noted that while winning against lower-ranked teams might give the impression of progress, more fundamental changes are needed for the team to compete effectively in the finals.
As Carlton enters their bye week in round 12, the club has a critical opportunity to reassess their strategies and approach as they enter the latter half of the season. The need for improvement in their kicking skills and structures is urgent if they hope to realise their potential and secure a finals berth.